Fantasy Baseball Picks (FanDuel) – April 21, 2026

Yesterday’s Results

All Day Slate Results
Top Score: 207.8
Cash Line: 123.4
Lineup Score: 130.3
Result: ✅ Cashed

Main Slate Results
Top Score: 196.5
Cash Line: 151.6
Lineup Score: 149.4
Result: ❌ Missed Cash

Yesterday I branched out a bit and added a main slate double up alongside the usual all day slate. In the end, we split the results — one cash and one near miss.

Honestly, that’s not a terrible outcome considering the boneheaded mistake I made by leaning into Seth Lugo plus a Baltimore mini stack with Gunnar Henderson and Taylor Ward in both lineups. When you make the same core mistake across multiple entries, it can drag everything down at once.

Even with that, both lineups were right around the cash line.

On the all day slate, we scored 130.3 against a 123.4 cash line, which was enough to get through comfortably enough. The top score there came in at 207.8.

On the main slate, we posted 149.4, but the cash line landed at 151.6, leaving us just short. That slate’s top score was 196.5.

What’s Changing Today

I’m taking a different approach moving forward.

I’ve been leaning a little too heavily into stacking teams in cash games, and that can become a real problem. Stacks make sense in tournaments when chasing ceiling, but in cash formats they can create unnecessary volatility.

If a team has a bad night, suddenly you can have two, three, or even four hitters all putting up poor scores at the same time. That’s exactly the kind of lineup fragility we want to avoid in double ups and head-to-head contests.

So today the focus shifts more heavily toward the Trust Score.

That means prioritizing players who consistently produce, avoid bust games, and give us steadier floors instead of forcing correlated stacks just for upside.

The goal is simple: less volatility, fewer dead spots, and stronger overall cash-game consistency.

Now let’s get into today’s projections.

Today’s Picks

Top Pitchers

Kris Bubic (KC) – $9800
Projection: 38.9 FD | Trust: 43.3 | Bust: 25% | Quality: 25%

Yoshinobu Yamamoto (LAD) – $10900
Projection: 37.8 FD | Trust: | Bust: | Quality:

Merrill Kelly (ARI) – $9200
Projection: 34.0 FD | Trust: | Bust: | Quality:

Jesus Luzardo (PHI) – $9000
Projection: 33.4 FD | Trust: | Bust: | Quality:

Luis Castillo (SEA) – $7500
Projection: 31.4 FD | Trust: 24.6 | Bust: 75% | Quality: 25%

Top Hitters

Shohei Ohtani (LAD OF) – $4000
Projection: 20.9 FD | Trust: 57.2 | Bust: 21%

Aaron Judge (NYY OF) – $4100
Projection: 20.7 FD | Trust: 62.9 | Bust: 16%

James Wood (WSH OF) – $4200
Projection: 19.9 FD | Trust: 71.8 | Bust: 26%

Cj Abrams (WSH SS) – $4100
Projection: 18.6 FD | Trust: 61.1 | Bust: 28%

Matt Olson (ATL 1B) – $3700
Projection: 17.5 FD | Trust: 66.3 | Bust: 16%

Corbin Carroll (ARI OF) – $3900
Projection: 17.5 FD | Trust: 58.1 | Bust: 25%

Gunnar Henderson (BAL SS) – $3700
Projection: 17.4 FD | Trust: 61.1 | Bust: 28%

Junior Caminero (TB 3B) – $3200
Projection: 17.3 FD | Trust: 52.4 | Bust: 26%

Randy Arozarena (SEA OF) – $3500
Projection: 17.0 FD | Trust: 54.5 | Bust: 26%

Elly De La Cruz (CIN SS) – $3800
Projection: 16.5 FD | Trust: 60.3 | Bust: 26%

Top Stacks

Fernando Tatis Jr. (SD OF) – $3700
Projection: 11.9 FD | Trust: 52.5

Manny Machado (SD 3B) – $3600
Projection: 11.8 FD | Trust: 49.2

Jackson Merrill (SD OF) – $3900
Projection: 10.6 FD | Trust: 56.5

Xander Bogaerts (SD SS) – $3500
Projection: 8.4 FD | Trust: 49.5

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (TOR 1B) – $3100
Projection: 13.7 FD | Trust: 45.5

Ernie Clement (TOR 2B/SS/3B/1B) – $2600
Projection: 8.6 FD | Trust: 44.2

Daulton Varsho (TOR OF) – $2800
Projection: 7.9 FD | Trust: 50.6

Nathan Lukes (TOR OF) – $2200
Projection: 7.8 FD | Trust: 16.8

Corbin Carroll (ARI OF) – $3900
Projection: 17.5 FD | Trust: 58.1

Geraldo Perdomo (ARI SS) – $2800
Projection: 11.7 FD | Trust: 49.4

Ketel Marte (ARI 2B) – $3000
Projection: 11.6 FD | Trust: 47.4

Lourdes Gurriel Jr. (ARI OF) – $2700
Projection: 10.6 FD | Trust: 50.0

By Position

C

Cal Raleigh (SEA C) – $2900
Projection: 15.3 FD | Trust: 38.2 | Bust: 42%

William Contreras (MIL C) – $3300
Projection: 14.5 FD | Trust: 57.4 | Bust: 18%

Shea Langeliers (ATH C) – $3600
Projection: 12.9 FD | Trust: 54.2 | Bust: 28%

Ben Rice (NYY C) – $4400
Projection: 12.4 FD | Trust: 71.1 | Bust: 17%

1B

Matt Olson (ATL 1B) – $3700
Projection: 17.5 FD | Trust: 66.3 | Bust: 16%

Nick Kurtz (ATH 1B) – $3100
Projection: 14.8 FD | Trust: 54.5 | Bust: 26%

Bryce Harper (PHI 1B) – $3300
Projection: 14.4 FD | Trust: 59.4 | Bust: 33%

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (TOR 1B) – $3100
Projection: 13.7 FD | Trust: 45.5 | Bust: 37%

2B

Brice Turang (MIL 2B) – $4300
Projection: 16.0 FD | Trust: 72.2 | Bust: 12%

Otto Lopez (MIA 2B) – $3500
Projection: 14.1 FD | Trust: 61.6 | Bust: 21%

Xavier Edwards (MIA 2B) – $3300
Projection: 13.7 FD | Trust: 60.8 | Bust: 30%

Nico Hoerner (CHC 2B) – $3700
Projection: 13.0 FD | Trust: 67.9 | Bust: 18%

3B

Junior Caminero (TB 3B) – $3200
Projection: 17.3 FD | Trust: 52.4 | Bust: 26%

Maikel Garcia (KC 3B) – $3000
Projection: 12.6 FD | Trust: 48.7 | Bust: 21%

Manny Machado (SD 3B) – $3600
Projection: 11.8 FD | Trust: 49.2 | Bust: 32%

Matt Chapman (SF 3B) – $2900
Projection: 11.2 FD | Trust: 54.7 | Bust: 37%

SS

Cj Abrams (WSH SS) – $4100
Projection: 18.6 FD | Trust: 61.1 | Bust: 28%

Gunnar Henderson (BAL SS) – $3700
Projection: 17.4 FD | Trust: 61.1 | Bust: 28%

Elly De La Cruz (CIN SS) – $3800
Projection: 16.5 FD | Trust: 60.3 | Bust: 26%

Trea Turner (PHI SS) – $3000
Projection: 14.4 FD | Trust: 55.8 | Bust: 22%

OF

Shohei Ohtani (LAD OF) – $4000
Projection: 20.9 FD | Trust: 57.2 | Bust: 21%

Aaron Judge (NYY OF) – $4100
Projection: 20.7 FD | Trust: 62.9 | Bust: 16%

James Wood (WSH OF) – $4200
Projection: 19.9 FD | Trust: 71.8 | Bust: 26%

Corbin Carroll (ARI OF) – $3900
Projection: 17.5 FD | Trust: 58.1 | Bust: 25%